Menu
Call
Contact
Blog

Evidence Code § 669: Negligence Per Se in California, and Whether a Traffic Ticket Proves Fault

  • No fee unless we win
  • 5.0 on Google
  • Avvo 10.0 Superb
  • Super Lawyers 2026 & 2027
David Gammill, trial attorney and founder of Gammill Law Accident & Injury Lawyers in Torrance, California

$100,000,000+

Recovered for Clients

$21,100,000

Wrongful Death VERDICT

$16,000,000

School Sexual Abuse VERDICT

$12,000,000

Whistleblower Retaliation VERDICT

Reviewed by David Gammill, California trial attorney · Last reviewed: November 15, 2026

A traffic ticket does not, by itself, prove fault in a California injury case. What changes the case is proof, made in the civil case, that the other driver broke a safety law and that the violation caused the crash. Under Evidence Code section 669, that proof creates a presumption that the driver failed to use due care. Lawyers call this negligence per se. The driver can try to rebut the presumption.

  • The rule: breaking a statute, ordinance or regulation is presumed to be a failure to use due care when four conditions are met: a violation, causation, the kind of harm the law was meant to prevent, and a person the law was meant to protect.
  • It can be rebutted: the violator may prove they did what a reasonably careful person who wanted to obey the law would have done.
  • A ticket is not the proof: a traffic conviction does not bind the civil court. The violation has to be proven with evidence.
  • Fault can still be shared: the presumption can apply to either side, and California divides fault by percentage.

What does Evidence Code section 669 say?

Subdivision (a) of Evidence Code section 669 reads:

“The failure of a person to exercise due care is presumed if: (1) He violated a statute, ordinance, or regulation of a public entity; (2) The violation proximately caused death or injury to person or property; (3) The death or injury resulted from an occurrence of the nature which the statute, ordinance, or regulation was designed to prevent; and (4) The person suffering the death or the injury to his person or property was one of the class of persons for whose protection the statute, ordinance, or regulation was adopted.”

“Due care” is the care a reasonably careful person would use. A “presumption” is a conclusion the law requires unless the other side disproves it. So when the four conditions are proven, the violator is treated as negligent unless they prove an excuse.

The California Supreme Court has said section 669 “codifies the common law doctrine of negligence per se” (Elsner v. Uveges (2004) 34 Cal.4th 915). Negligence per se is not a separate claim. It is an evidentiary rule used inside an ordinary negligence claim (Quiroz v. Seventh Ave. Center (2006) 140 Cal.App.4th 1256).

What are the four elements, and who decides them?

  1. A violation of a statute, ordinance or regulation of a public entity. In a crash case this is most often a Vehicle Code section.
  2. Causation. The violation was a cause of the death or injury.
  3. The right kind of harm. The law was designed to prevent this kind of event.
  4. The right kind of person. The law was adopted to protect people like the one injured.

The first two elements are normally questions of fact for the jury. The last two are decided by the judge, because they turn on what the statute means (Ramirez v. Nelson (2008) 44 Cal.4th 908, 917-918). If either of the last two is missing, section 669 does not apply.

Traffic safety laws usually meet the last two elements when one road user hurts another. Examples are the basic speed law, Vehicle Code § 22350, and the pedestrian right-of-way law, which requires drivers to yield to a pedestrian crossing in a marked crosswalk or in an unmarked crosswalk at an intersection.

When the evidence supports a violation, the jury must be told what the violation means. In Drury v. Ryan (2025) 109 Cal.App.5th 1102, a left-turn crash case under Vehicle Code section 21801, the trial judge read the statute to the jury but refused the negligence per se instruction, CACI No. 418. The Court of Appeal reversed and ordered a new trial.

Does the other driver’s ticket prove fault?

No. A citation is an officer’s charge, not a court finding. Section 669 asks whether the person “violated” the law, not whether they were cited. Several statutes limit what a ticket or conviction can do in the civil case:

  • A traffic conviction does not bind the civil court. Under Vehicle Code section 40834, a conviction for a Vehicle Code violation, or for a local ordinance on operating a motor vehicle, “shall not be res judicata or constitute a collateral estoppel of any issue determined therein in any subsequent civil action.” The driver may contest the same facts again.
  • Only felony judgments get the hearsay exception. Evidence Code section 1300 lets a final judgment of conviction be used in a civil case to prove a fact essential to it only for “a crime punishable as a felony.” Most traffic offenses are not.
  • A no contest plea is protected. Under Penal Code section 1016, in cases not punishable as felonies, a no contest (nolo contendere) plea “may not be used against the defendant as an admission in any civil suit” growing out of the same act.
  • DMV suspension records stay out. Vehicle Code section 40832 says no record of a license suspension or revocation by the DMV, and no testimony from the hearing that led to it, “shall be admissible as evidence in any court in any civil action.” This section covers DMV license actions, not tickets.

A guilty plea is different. The California Supreme Court has held that a guilty plea can be offered in a later civil case as the person’s own admission. It is evidence for the jury to weigh, not a conclusive finding (Vaughn v. Jonas (1948) 31 Cal.2d 586, 595-596).

So the violation has to be proven in the civil case with evidence: witnesses, photographs, video, vehicle data and the driver’s own statements. Gathering that proof early is a large part of what a Torrance car accident lawyer does after a crash. The police report is a common starting point. See how to get a Torrance police accident report.

How can the driver rebut the presumption?

Section 669, subdivision (b)(1), allows the presumption to be rebutted by proof that the violator “did what might reasonably be expected of a person of ordinary prudence, acting under similar circumstances, who desired to comply with the law.” The burden is on the violator. Section 669 is a presumption affecting the burden of proof (Evidence Code section 660), which means the party it operates against must prove that the presumed fact is not true (Evidence Code section 606).

The wording comes from Alarid v. Vanier (1958) 50 Cal.2d 617, 624. A driver’s brakes failed and he struck a stopped car from behind. The parties agreed that the brake violation raised a presumption of negligence. The Supreme Court held that his evidence of inspection and maintenance was enough for a jury to decide whether he was excused, and it affirmed the verdict in his favor.

The standard jury instruction on excuse, CACI No. 420, lists the usual grounds: incapacity, inability to obey the law despite reasonable care, an emergency the person did not cause, or a greater risk of harm from obeying.

Children have a separate rule. Under subdivision (b)(2), a child may rebut the presumption by showing the care ordinarily used by children of the same maturity, intelligence and capacity. That rule does not apply to “an activity normally engaged in only by adults and requiring adult qualifications.” The notes to CACI No. 421 give driving as an example.

Does causation still have to be proven?

Yes. Causation is one of the four elements, so there is no presumption without it. A statute can supply the standard of care, but “the plaintiff still has the burden of proving causation” (David v. Hernandez (2014) 226 Cal.App.4th 578, 584). The jury instruction, CACI No. 418, requires both a violation and that the violation was “a substantial factor in bringing about the harm.” If either is missing, jurors decide negligence under the ordinary reasonable-care standard.

Two examples. Leaving the scene violates California’s hit-and-run law, but the leaving happens after the impact, so that violation does not by itself show who caused the collision. And for speed, Vehicle Code section 40831 says that proof of speed above a prima facie limit “does not establish negligence as a matter of law.”

How does negligence per se work with comparative fault?

California uses pure comparative negligence. An injured person’s own negligence does not bar recovery. Instead, “the damages awarded shall be diminished in proportion to the amount of negligence attributable to the person recovering” (Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804, 828-829).

Section 669 works in both directions. CACI No. 418 is written so it can be given against a plaintiff or a defendant. A defendant can use the injured person’s own violation to argue for a share of the fault. In Li itself, the plaintiff had made an unsafe left turn across oncoming traffic.

A presumption against one driver does not end the case. The jury still assigns percentages. In David v. Hernandez, where a truck had been parked illegally facing traffic, the Court of Appeal ordered a new trial so a jury could apply comparative fault between the two drivers.

What does section 669.1 say about government policies and manuals?

Evidence Code section 669.1 covers a government body’s internal rules for its own employees. A “rule, policy, manual, or guideline of state or local government” that sets standards of conduct for public employees is not a “statute, ordinance, or regulation” under section 669, unless it was formally adopted as a statute, as an ordinance, or as a regulation under the state or federal Administrative Procedure Act.

The section “affects only the presumption.” It does not decide whether the document is admissible. In Lugtu v. California Highway Patrol (2001) 26 Cal.4th 703, an officer directed a speeding car to stop in a freeway’s center median, where a pickup truck struck it. The Supreme Court held that the CHP Officer Safety Manual could not create a presumption of negligence, because nothing showed it had been adopted under the Administrative Procedure Act. The jury could still consider it as evidence of whether the officer used due care.

Frequently asked questions

The other driver was not ticketed. Can I still use section 669?

Yes. The statute requires a violation, not a citation.

The other driver paid the ticket or was convicted. Is fault settled?

No. Under Vehicle Code section 40834 a traffic conviction does not bind the civil court. A guilty plea may be offered as an admission, but it is not conclusive.

I got a ticket too. Does that end my claim?

No. The same limits apply to your ticket. If your own violation is proven and was a cause of the crash, your damages are reduced by your percentage of fault. They are not eliminated.

Sources

  1. Cal. Evid. Code § 669. Presumption of failure to use due care from violation of a statute, ordinance or regulation; rebuttal.
  2. Cal. Evid. Code § 669.1. Government rules, policies, manuals and guidelines.
  3. Cal. Evid. Code § 660 and § 606. Presumptions affecting the burden of proof.
  4. Cal. Evid. Code § 1300. Judgment of felony conviction offered in a civil action.
  5. Cal. Veh. Code § 40834. Traffic conviction is not res judicata or collateral estoppel in a later civil action.
  6. Cal. Veh. Code § 40832. DMV suspension and revocation records not admissible in civil actions.
  7. Cal. Veh. Code § 40831. Speed above a prima facie limit does not establish negligence as a matter of law.
  8. Cal. Veh. Code § 21950. Pedestrian right-of-way in crosswalks.
  9. Cal. Penal Code § 1016. Effect of a nolo contendere plea in a later civil suit.
  10. Alarid v. Vanier (1958) 50 Cal.2d 617.
  11. Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804.
  12. Vaughn v. Jonas (1948) 31 Cal.2d 586.
  13. Lugtu v. California Highway Patrol (2001) 26 Cal.4th 703.
  14. Elsner v. Uveges (2004) 34 Cal.4th 915.
  15. Ramirez v. Nelson (2008) 44 Cal.4th 908.
  16. Quiroz v. Seventh Ave. Center (2006) 140 Cal.App.4th 1256.
  17. David v. Hernandez (2014) 226 Cal.App.4th 578.
  18. Drury v. Ryan (2025) 109 Cal.App.5th 1102.
  19. Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (2026 edition), CACI Nos. 418, 419, 420 and 421.

Talk to a Lawyer About Your Case

If you were injured and this rule affects your case, get a free case evaluation or call 310-750-4149. There are no upfront legal fees; a fee is collected only if we win, under a written contingency fee agreement that complies with California law. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Disclaimer: This article is educational and informational in nature. It does not constitute legal advice for any specific situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts; consult a licensed California attorney about your own circumstances.

CallFree Case Review
Ask Gammill AI Calculator