Menu
Call
Contact
Blog

The Howell Rule: Medical-Damages Evidence in California Injury Trials

By David Gammill, Attorney

Legally reviewed: October 26, 2026 | Updated: October 26, 2026. Cases are cited to the official reports with pin cites.

Part of the California Evidence Code Practitioner Series.

What is the Howell rule in one sentence?

A California plaintiff may recover past medical damages no greater than the amount actually paid or incurred. When a provider has agreed in advance to accept less than its bill as full payment, the unpaid billed amount is not relevant to past medical damages. (Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions, Inc. (2011) 52 Cal.4th 541, 566–567 (Howell).) The holding:

“[A]n injured plaintiff whose medical expenses are paid through private insurance may recover as economic damages no more than the amounts paid by the plaintiff or his or her insurer for the medical services received or still owing at the time of trial.” (Howell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p. 566.)

The governing principle is that “[t]o be recoverable, a medical expense must be both incurred and reasonable.” (Id. at p. 555.) Recovery is the lesser of the amount paid or incurred and the reasonable value of the services (id. at p. 556). Howell did not abolish the collateral source rule (see Helfend v. Southern Cal. Rapid Transit Dist. (1970) 2 Cal.3d 1, 6). The plaintiff still recovers amounts the insurer paid, and evidence that an insurer paid them “remains . . . generally inadmissible.” (Howell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p. 567.) CACI No. 3903A frames the jury question: the plaintiff “must prove the reasonable cost of reasonably necessary medical care.”

What evidence does Howell keep out, and what comes in?

For an insured plaintiff’s past medical expenses, the amount paid (plus any amount still owing) is relevant and admissible. The full billed amount the provider agreed not to collect is not. And the fact that insurance paid stays out.

“Where the provider has, by prior agreement, accepted less than a billed amount as full payment, evidence of the full billed amount is not itself relevant on the issue of past medical expenses. We express no opinion as to its relevance or admissibility on other issues, such as noneconomic damages or future medical expenses.” (Howell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p. 567.)

Corenbaum v. Lampkin (2013) 215 Cal.App.4th 1308 answered the questions Howell left open. It held that evidence of the full amounts billed “was not relevant to the amount of damages for past medical services, damages for their future medical care, or noneconomic damages.” (Id. at p. 1319; see id. at pp. 1330–1333.) Full billed amounts for past care also “cannot support an expert opinion on the reasonable value of future medical services.” (Id. at p. 1331.) Cuevas v. Contra Costa County (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 163, 182 agreed.

Are unpaid bills admissible at all? The Ochoa–Pebley–Qaadir split

It depends on which line of authority the trial court follows. One line holds that unpaid billed amounts are not evidence of reasonable value. The other admits them when the plaintiff actually incurred them and offers separate evidence of reasonable value. When published Courts of Appeal conflict, the trial court “can and must make a choice between the conflicting decisions.” (Auto Equity Sales, Inc. v. Superior Court (1962) 57 Cal.2d 450, 456.)

CasePositionKey language
Ochoa v. Dorado (2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 120 (2d Dist., Div. 3)Unpaid billed amounts are not relevant to reasonable value, even without a prior agreement to accept less“[E]vidence of unpaid medical bills cannot support an award of damages for past medical expenses.” (Id. at pp. 138–139; see id. at pp. 135–136.)
Bermudez v. Ciolek (2015) 237 Cal.App.4th 1311 (4th Dist., Div. 3)Uninsured plaintiff: bills are relevant to the amount incurred and to reasonable value, but are not enough aloneThe amount incurred by an uninsured patient “is not sufficient evidence on its own to prove the reasonable amount of medical damages.” (Id. at p. 1337; see id. at p. 1335.) Bermudez read Ochoa as holding only that unpaid bills, without more, are not substantial evidence (id. at p. 1337).
Pebley v. Santa Clara Organics, LLC (2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 1266 (2d Dist., Div. 6)An insured plaintiff treating outside the plan on a lien is treated as uninsuredSuch a plaintiff “shall be considered uninsured, as opposed to insured, for the purpose of determining economic damages.” (Id. at p. 1269; see id. at p. 1275.)
Qaadir v. Figueroa (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 790 (2d Dist., Div. 8)Acknowledges the split and sides with Pebley; adds an “actually incurred” prerequisiteUnpaid bills are relevant to past medical damages “only if he can show he actually incurred those amounts.” (Id. at p. 798.)

Practice points:

How does Howell apply to each type of plaintiff?

Payment status controls the evidence. In-network insured plaintiffs are capped at the amounts paid. Uninsured, lien, and outside-the-plan plaintiffs may offer billed amounts, but must prove they incurred them and must prove reasonable value. Special statutes govern public entities and, for accidents on or after January 1, 2027, network-company (rideshare and delivery) auto cases with lien-based treatment.

Plaintiff situationRuleAuthority
Insured, in-network; provider accepted negotiated rateRecovery capped at the amount paid or still owing; the full bill is not relevant to past, future, or noneconomic damagesHowell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at pp. 566–567; Corenbaum, supra, 215 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1319, 1330–1333
Insured but treated outside the plan on a lienTreated as uninsured; bills admissible with proof they were incurred and evidence of reasonable valuePebley, supra, 22 Cal.App.5th at p. 1269; Qaadir, supra, 67 Cal.App.5th at p. 804; contra, Ochoa, supra, 228 Cal.App.4th at pp. 138–139
UninsuredLesser of amount incurred and reasonable value; bills relevant but not sufficient aloneBermudez, supra, 237 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1330–1331, 1335, 1337
Medi-Cal paidRecovery limited to the amount Medi-Cal paid where the plaintiff is not liable for the balanceHanif v. Housing Authority (1988) 200 Cal.App.3d 635, 639–641, 643–644; Howell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at pp. 552–553
Lien sold to a medical-finance companyThe factor’s purchase price does not cap damages; the court has § 352 discretion over that evidenceMoore v. Mercer (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 424, 427–428; Katiuzhinsky v. Perry (2007) 152 Cal.App.4th 1288; see Uspenskaya v. Meline (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th 996, 1003, 1007
Hospital Lien Act servicesThe HLA requires emergency services; the lien covers emergency and ongoing services only until discharge; later care is measured under Howell. Conflicts with NewtonYaffee v. Skeen (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th 1281, 1301, 1305–1307; contra, Newton v. Clemons (2003) 110 Cal.App.4th 1, 10–13
Public-entity defendantPost-verdict collateral-source procedure under Gov. Code, § 985; Howell left it untouchedHowell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p. 567; CACI No. 3923
Gratuitous write-off by providerTreated as a collateral sourceSanchez v. Strickland (2011) 200 Cal.App.4th 758, 769
Network-company auto cases; accident on or after Jan. 1, 2027; lien-based treatmentStatutory cap at the 70th percentile of FAIR Health billed charges; above-cap amounts inadmissibleCiv. Code, § 3333.9, added by Stats. 2026, ch. 17 (Sen. Bill No. 623)

This page addresses private insurance, lien, uninsured, Medi-Cal, and the statutory categories above. It does not address Medicare-specific issues.

What did Yaffee hold about the Hospital Lien Act, and what did it not hold?

Yaffee v. Skeen (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th 1281 made three separate rulings. Keep them apart.

  1. The HLA requires emergency services. A hospital must provide emergency services before it can assert a lien under Civil Code section 3045.1 (Yaffee, supra, 106 Cal.App.5th at p. 1301).
  2. “Ongoing” services end at discharge. The lien covers services “while the patient remains undischarged” after admission through the emergency room. Post-discharge care is measured under Howell, so admitting reasonable-value evidence above the insurer-paid amounts for that care was prejudicial error, and the past-medical award was vacated (Yaffee, supra, 106 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1305–1308). Yaffee expressly disagreed with Newton v. Clemons (2003) 110 Cal.App.4th 1, 10–13, which had read “ongoing” more broadly (Yaffee, supra, 106 Cal.App.5th at p. 1305). Trial courts outside the Third District may face both decisions (Auto Equity Sales, supra, 57 Cal.2d at p. 456).
  3. The future-medical reversal was a substantial-evidence ruling, not a Howell ruling. The award included a dorsal root ganglion stimulator that the doctors could not say with reasonable certainty would be needed. Because the verdict form did not itemize future medical expenses, the whole future-medical award was reversed for a new trial (Yaffee, supra, 106 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1310–1311).

What does SB 623 change starting in 2027?

SB 623 caps lien-based medical damages in network-company (rideshare and delivery) auto cases. It adds Civil Code section 3333.9, which limits recoverable past medical damages from lien-based providers to the 70th percentile of billed charges in the FAIR Health database (or a comparable database). Billed or lien amounts above the cap are inadmissible for any purpose. (Civ. Code, § 3333.9, added by Stats. 2026, ch. 17 (Sen. Bill No. 623).) It applies to claims against a network company, its subsidiary, or an app-based driver arising out of an automobile accident on or after January 1, 2027, where the claimant treated with a lien-based provider (id., subd. (a)(1)). It does not apply to services, liens, or assignments arising before that date (id., subd. (a)(2)).

Under the Proposition 22 definitions, a “network company” is a delivery network company or a transportation network company. An “app-based driver” is a delivery courier, TNC driver, or charter-party driver who meets the conditions of Business and Professions Code section 7451 (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 7463, subds. (a), (l)). Delivery-app crashes are therefore covered, not just rideshare crashes. Expect disputes over whether a particular driver meets the section 7451 conditions.

FeatureWhat section 3333.9 provides
Cap70th percentile of FAIR Health (or comparable) billed charges for the service, area, and time (subd. (b)(1)(A))
Above-cap evidenceNo party may present billed or lien amounts above the cap, or refer to the section or the cap; such evidence is inadmissible for any purpose (subd. (b)(2))
Below-cap billsAdmissible; recovery cannot exceed the actual billed amount (subd. (b)(3)–(4))
Exceeding the capPretrial plaintiff motion; clear and convincing evidence plus expert testimony for exceptionally rare or highly specialized care; fees to the opposing party if the motion is denied (subd. (b)(1)(C))
BillingItemized CPT/HCPCS/ICD-coded bills; 30-day cure after written notice (subd. (b)(5))
Sold or factored liensRecovery capped at the consideration paid; agreements discoverable and disclosed within 30 days (subd. (c))
Referral relationshipsDiscoverable; provider declaration on attorney referrals over the prior 24 months (subd. (d))
Attorney conductSpecified referral, ownership, kickback, and lien-reduction practices are unlawful and subject to State Bar discipline (subd. (e))
Collateral source ruleNot abrogated (subd. (a)(5)); defendant may still challenge reasonableness (subd. (b)(1)(B))

Outside its scope, SB 623 leaves Howell and the cases above unchanged.

How do you prove reasonable value at trial?

Lay a records foundation for every bill and payment record. Then prove the amounts were incurred, and offer a qualified reasonable-value opinion that does not rest on billed amounts the plaintiff never incurred. Bills and payment ledgers usually come in as business records under Evid. Code, § 1271, often through a § 1561 custodian affidavit; see the § 1271 business records foundation guide. What a billing expert may relate from records not in evidence is covered in the Sanchez and expert-basis guide.

  1. Records: subpoena the itemized bill, the payment and adjustment ledger, and any lien-sale or factoring agreement.
  2. Incurred: establish what was paid, what remains owed, and that the plaintiff is liable for the balance (Qaadir, supra, 67 Cal.App.5th at p. 798). A plaintiff “must prove that she actually incurred the medical expenses.” (Moore, supra, 4 Cal.App.5th at p. 437.)
  3. Reasonable value: use a retained expert who can explain market or exchange value, or a nonretained treating physician within the limits Ochoa describes (Bermudez, supra, 237 Cal.App.4th at p. 1337; Ochoa, supra, 228 Cal.App.4th at pp. 140–141).
  4. Future care: an injured plaintiff “is entitled to recover the reasonable value of medical services that are reasonably certain to be necessary in the future” (Cuevas, supra, 11 Cal.App.5th at p. 182). The cost opinion may not rest on full billed past amounts (Corenbaum, supra, 215 Cal.App.4th at p. 1331).

Sample questions for a defense billing witness: “Does your data set reflect amounts paid or amounts billed?” “Which of these rates are Medicare allowable rates, and did the plaintiff’s providers accept them?” “Did you review the lien agreement and the provider’s collection history?”

What are the common objections and responses?

Raise Howell issues by motion in limine with a hearing under Evidence Code section 402 before opening statements, and then object on the specific ground at trial (Evid. Code, § 353).

ObjectionResponse
“Irrelevant under Howell: full billed amounts for an insured plaintiff.”Well taken if the provider accepted a negotiated rate (Howell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p. 567; Corenbaum, supra, 215 Cal.App.4th at p. 1319). If the plaintiff treated on a lien outside the plan, respond with Pebley and Qaadir; expect Ochoa in reply.
“No showing the plaintiff incurred these unpaid bills.”Qaadir requires that showing before admission (Qaadir, supra, 67 Cal.App.5th at pp. 798, 805). Lay it through the lien agreement and the plaintiff’s testimony.
“Bills alone do not prove reasonable value.”Agreed; offer the reasonable-value witness (Bermudez, supra, 237 Cal.App.4th at p. 1337).
“Insurance is inadmissible (Evid. Code, § 352).”The source of payment is generally inadmissible (Howell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p. 567; CACI No. 105; Pebley, supra, 22 Cal.App.5th at p. 1278). Request a limiting instruction (Evid. Code, § 355) if any reference comes in.
“Referral evidence is prejudicial.”Qaadir held attorney-referral evidence relevant to reasonable value and bias (Qaadir, supra, 67 Cal.App.5th at p. 808); argue § 352 on the specific facts.
“The factor’s price should cap damages.”Moore, supra, 4 Cal.App.5th at pp. 427–428: it does not; the court has § 352 discretion. Absent evidence of a nexus to reasonable value, the factor’s payment has limited probative value (Uspenskaya, supra, 241 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1003, 1007).
“The HLA lets the hospital recover full charges for all later care.”Yaffee: only until discharge (Yaffee, supra, 106 Cal.App.5th at p. 1307). Expect Newton in reply.
“The expert relied on billed amounts for future care.”Corenbaum, supra, 215 Cal.App.4th at p. 1331; Cuevas, supra, 11 Cal.App.5th at p. 182. Move to strike or limit the opinion.

Which CACI instructions, motions, and post-trial tools apply?

The core tools are CACI No. 3903A (medical expenses), CACI No. 105 (insurance), a Howell motion in limine with a section 402 hearing, an itemized verdict form, and a post-trial new-trial motion for excessive damages with remittitur. Under Howell, a defendant whose jury heard the amount accepted as full payment but awarded more “may move for a new trial on grounds of excessive damages” (Code Civ. Proc., § 657, subd. 5), and “[a] nonstatutory ‘Hanif motion’ is unnecessary.” (Howell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p. 567.) The court may condition the new trial on the plaintiff accepting a reduction (Code Civ. Proc., § 662.5, subd. (a)(2); Howell cited the pre-2012 version as subd. (b)).

How does this play out in PI practice?

Leading authorities

AuthorityHolding used on this page
Hanif v. Housing Authority (1988) 200 Cal.App.3d 635, 641Medi-Cal plaintiff limited to the amount paid
Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions, Inc. (2011) 52 Cal.4th 541, 566–567Recovery limited to amounts paid or incurred; negotiated write-off not relevant to past medical
Corenbaum v. Lampkin (2013) 215 Cal.App.4th 1308, 1319, 1330–1333Full bills not relevant to past, future, or noneconomic damages
Ochoa v. Dorado (2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 120, 135–139Unpaid bills not evidence of reasonable value
Bermudez v. Ciolek (2015) 237 Cal.App.4th 1311, 1330–1331, 1335, 1337Uninsured plaintiff: bills relevant but insufficient alone
Moore v. Mercer (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 424, 427–428Factoring price does not cap damages; § 352 discretion
Cuevas v. Contra Costa County (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 163, 182Future care: reasonable value of services reasonably certain to be necessary; no billed-amount basis for a future-care opinion
Pebley v. Santa Clara Organics, LLC (2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 1266, 1269Out-of-plan lien plaintiff treated as uninsured
Qaadir v. Figueroa (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 790, 797–798, 804–805, 808Split acknowledged; “actually incurred” prerequisite; referral evidence relevant
Yaffee v. Skeen (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th 1281, 1301, 1305–1311HLA ends at discharge (disagreeing with Newton); future award reversed for lack of substantial evidence
Civ. Code, § 3333.9, added by Stats. 2026, ch. 17Lien-provider cap in network-company auto cases from 2027

Frequently asked questions

Can an insured plaintiff show the jury the full bill?

Not when the provider accepted a negotiated rate (Howell, supra, 52 Cal.4th at p. 567). Corenbaum extends the bar to future and noneconomic damages.

What if the plaintiff treated on a lien?

Courts are split. Under Pebley and Qaadir, the plaintiff is treated as uninsured, and the bills come in on proof they were incurred plus evidence of reasonable value. Ochoa treats unpaid bills as no evidence of reasonable value.

Does the Hospital Lien Act let a hospital recover full charges for all later care?

Not under Yaffee, which ends HLA coverage at discharge, but Newton read “ongoing” more broadly.

Did 2026 legislation change Howell?

Only for network-company (rideshare and delivery) auto cases with lien-based treatment arising from accidents on or after January 1, 2027 (Civ. Code, § 3333.9, added by Stats. 2026, ch. 17).

Related pages

About the author

David Gammill is a California trial lawyer who served seven years as a Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney and has tried more than 100 cases to verdict. He represents injured people in the South Bay and across Los Angeles County. State Bar of California No. 258286 (State Bar profile).

Medical damages contested in a case headed for trial?

Gammill Law accepts trial referrals and co-counsel arrangements from other attorneys. To talk through medical-damages evidence or trial strategy in a California injury case, reach David Gammill through our For Attorneys page.

This page is educational material for lawyers, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Verify current statutes, rules, and case law, including subsequent history, before relying on it.

CallFree Case Review
Ask Gammill AI Calculator