Menu
Call
Contact
Blog

California Evidence Code: A Practitioner’s Guide for Personal Injury Trial Lawyers

By David Gammill, Attorney

Legally reviewed: October 26, 2026 | Updated: October 26, 2026. Cases are cited to the official reports with pin cites.

Part of the California Evidence Code Practitioner Series. Unless otherwise indicated, statutory references are to the Evidence Code.

Short answer: The Evidence Code governs admissibility “in every action before the Supreme Court or a court of appeal or superior court,” except as otherwise provided by statute. (§ 300.) In a personal injury trial, most rulings turn on five areas. They are relevance and section 352; preserving objections (§§ 353–355); preliminary facts (§§ 400–405); the hearsay exceptions (§§ 1200–1390); and expert opinion (§§ 801–805, as construed in Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California (2012) 55 Cal.4th 747 (Sargon)). California departs from the Federal Rules of Evidence in ways that change outcomes. Examples include subsequent remedial measures, employee statements, medical-history statements and medical-causation experts. In auto cases, Vehicle Code provisions also exclude accident reports, DMV records and the preclusive effect of traffic convictions.

What does the California Evidence Code cover, and where are the rules PI lawyers use?

The Evidence Code has 11 divisions, enacted by Stats. 1965, ch. 299. This map shows where the rules used in PI trials sit and which page in this series covers them.

DivisionSectionsWhat it governsRules PI lawyers use mostSeries page
1. Preliminary Provisions1–12ConstructionNoneNone
2. Words and Phrases Defined100–260Definitions§ 160 (“law”), § 225 (“statement”), § 240 (unavailability)Hearsay exceptions
3. General Provisions300–413Scope, relevance, admitting and excluding evidence, preliminary facts§§ 300, 350–356, 351.2, 352, 402–405This page
4. Judicial Notice450–460Judicial noticeNoneNone
5. Burdens; Presumptions and Inferences500–670Burdens of proof and production; presumptions§ 669 (negligence per se)This page
6. Witnesses700–795Competency, examination, expert witnesses, credibility§ 721 (cross-examining experts), § 770, § 791Hearsay exceptions
7. Opinion Testimony and Scientific Evidence800–870Lay and expert opinion§§ 800–805, 801.1This page; Sanchez guide
8. Privileges900–1070PrivilegesLawyer-client and physician-patient privileges and their exceptionsPlanned
9. Evidence Affected or Excluded by Extrinsic Policies1100–1162Character evidence; mediation confidentiality; policy exclusions§ 1101, §§ 1115–1129, 1151, 1152, 1154, 1155, 1160This page
10. Hearsay Evidence1200–1390Hearsay rule and exceptions§§ 1200, 1201, 1220–1224, 1240, 1250, 1271, 1280Hearsay exceptions
11. Writings1400–1605Authentication, secondary evidence, business-records production§§ 1400–1401, 1521, 1560–1562§ 1271 guide

Does the California Evidence Code apply in federal court?

Mostly no. The Evidence Code applies in California’s Supreme Court, Courts of Appeal and superior courts. (§ 300.) In federal court, the Federal Rules of Evidence govern admissibility, with two carve-outs for state-law claims in civil cases:

Lawyers who move between forums should check each evidentiary assumption against the forum’s rule. The table below lists the differences that come up most in PI cases.

What are the most important differences between the California Evidence Code and the Federal Rules of Evidence?

The differences that most often change a PI ruling involve remedial measures, compromise and insurance evidence, expert gatekeeping, medical-causation experts, records foundation, immigration status and the hearsay exceptions. Each row compares statutory text to rule text; case law may refine either side.

IssueCaliforniaFederal Rules of EvidencePractice consequence
Undue prejudice§ 352: exclude if probative value is “substantially outweighed” by undue consumption of time or “substantial danger of undue prejudice, of confusing the issues, or of misleading the jury”Rule 403: adds “wasting time, or needlessly presenting cumulative evidence”; uses “unfair prejudice”Cite § 352 in state court; the balancing is similar
Subsequent remedial measures§ 1151: inadmissible “to prove negligence or culpable conduct.” Does not apply to strict products liability (Ault v. International Harvester Co. (1974) 13 Cal.3d 113, 117 (Ault))Rule 407: also bars proof of “a defect in a product or its design; or a need for a warning or instruction”; lists other purposesPost-accident design changes can come in on a California strict-liability count
Compromise offers§ 1152: offers “in compromise or from humanitarian motives,” and statements in negotiation, inadmissible to prove liability; § 1154: claimant’s offers to accept lessRule 408: also bars use “to impeach by a prior inconsistent statement or a contradiction”; lists bias and undue delay as other purposesCalifornia’s text adds humanitarian payments; check case law before using settlement talk to impeach
Insurance§ 1155: inadmissible “to prove negligence or other wrongdoing”; text lists no other purposesRule 411: expressly allows bias, agency, ownership or controlResearch California authority before offering insurance for another purpose
Apologies§ 1160: sympathy statements inadmissible to prove liability; “[a] statement of fault … shall not be inadmissible”No general rule; Rule 409 covers offers to pay medical expensesRedact the sympathy; offer the fault clause under § 1220
Expert gatekeeping§§ 801, subd. (b), 802 and Sargon: exclude opinions based on improper matter, unsupported reasons or speculation; general acceptance under People v. Kelly (1976) 17 Cal.3d 24, 30 (Kelly) for new scientific techniquesRule 702: proponent shows admissibility requirements are “more likely than not” met (2023 amendment)Different standards and case law; do not cite Daubert as California authority
Medical-causation rebuttal§ 801.1 (general civil cases): a defense expert offering an alternative cause must opine that it exists “to a reasonable medical probability,” with a carve-out in subd. (b)No counterpartMove to limit “possible cause” testimony from defense experts
Learned treatises§ 721, subd. (b): cross-examination only on listed conditions; portions “may be read into evidence but may not be received as exhibits”Rule 803(18): hearsay exception for reliable treatises used with an expertA treatise does not come in for its truth under California’s hearsay rules
Business-records foundation§ 1561–§ 1562: custodian affidavit with subpoenaed records; § 1271 requirements must still be metRule 803(6) and Rule 902(11): certification with advance written notice; opponent must show untrustworthinessSee the § 1271 guide
Hearsay exceptionsNo residual exception; no general present-sense-impression, medical-diagnosis or employee-statement exception; unsworn prior inconsistent statements admissible for truth (§ 1235)Rule 807, Rule 803(1), (4), Rule 801(d)(1)(A), (d)(2)(D)Full list: California vs. FRE hearsay gap table
Immigration status§ 351.2: in PI and wrongful-death actions, not admissible and not discoverableNo counterpartMove in limine and object in discovery
Accident reports and DMV recordsVeh. Code, § 20013 (accident reports); §§ 40832–40834 (DMV records, financial-responsibility reports, convictions)No counterpartSee the auto-case section below

How do you preserve an evidentiary objection in a California trial?

Object on the record, on time, on a specific ground; make an offer of proof when your evidence is excluded; and ask for a limiting instruction when evidence comes in for one purpose. These statutes do the work:

StatuteWhat it requiresWhat to say or do
§ 353Reversal for erroneous admission requires an objection or motion to strike “timely made and so stated as to make clear the specific ground,” plus a miscarriage of justice“Objection, hearsay, Evidence Code section 1200; no exception applies.” Move to strike if the answer comes before the objection
§ 354Reversal for erroneous exclusion requires that “the substance, purpose, and relevance of the excluded evidence” was made known, unless futile or sought on cross-examinationOffer of proof: what the witness would say, why it is relevant, and the exception or theory
§ 355Evidence admissible for one purpose or party: “the court upon request shall restrict the evidence to its proper scope and instruct the jury accordingly”Request CACI No. 206 (limited purpose) or CACI No. 207 (one party)
§ 402The court may decide admissibility outside the jury’s presence; a ruling “implies whatever finding of fact is prerequisite thereto”Request a section 402 hearing for contested foundations; make the factual record before the ruling
§ 356When part of a conversation or writing is offered, the adverse party may inquire into “the whole on the same subject”Invoke completeness when an opponent excerpts a statement

Motions in limine are the practical way to get rulings before opening statements. Identify the specific evidence, the statute and the relief (exclude, admit or limit), and request a section 402 hearing where foundation is disputed. A limiting instruction under CACI No. 206 does not cure Sanchez problems with an expert relating case-specific hearsay. CACI’s Directions for Use say so, citing People v. Sanchez (2016) 63 Cal.4th 665, 684 (Sanchez).

Who decides preliminary facts in California: the judge or the jury?

The judge decides most admissibility facts under section 405. For the facts listed in section 403, the proponent need only make a prima facie showing.

§ 403: “evidence sufficient to sustain a finding”§ 405: the court decides
Relevance that depends on a preliminary factPreliminary facts “not governed by Section 403 or 404”
Personal knowledge of a witnessMost hearsay-exception foundations, such as spontaneity under § 1240 (see the hearsay page)
Authenticity of a writing (see also § 1400)The court indicates who bears the burdens “as implied by the rule of law under which the question arises”
Whether a particular person made the statementIf the preliminary fact is also an issue in the case, the jury is not told of the court’s finding (§ 405, subd. (b))

How does Evidence Code section 352 work in a personal injury trial?

Section 352 lets the court exclude evidence only when its probative value is “substantially outweighed” by the probability of undue consumption of time or a “substantial danger of undue prejudice, of confusing the issues, or of misleading the jury.” (§ 352.) Damaging is not the same as prejudicial. The “prejudice” in section 352 “applies to evidence which uniquely tends to evoke an emotional bias against the defendant as an individual and which has very little effect on the issues. In applying section 352, ‘prejudicial’ is not synonymous with ‘damaging.'” (People v. Karis (1988) 46 Cal.3d 612, 638, quoting People v. Yu (1983) 143 Cal.App.3d 358, 377.)

Common section 352 fights in PI trials: injury and scene photographs; day-in-the-life video; prior accidents and claims (with section 1101’s character limits); a party’s prior DUI; and social-media posts. Frame the probative value specifically (what fact it proves and why other evidence is weaker), and offer alternatives such as fewer photos or a redacted clip.

Immigration status is out by statute. “In a civil action for personal injury or wrongful death, evidence of a person’s immigration status shall not be admitted into evidence, nor shall discovery into a person’s immigration status be permitted.” (§ 351.2, subd. (a).)

Which policy-based exclusions matter most in PI cases?

Division 9 excludes several categories of evidence for policy reasons, but each has limits that a careful offer can use. The right-hand column is usually where the fight is.

SectionExcludesWhat the text leaves open
§ 1151Post-event remedial measures, “to prove negligence or culpable conduct”Strict products liability counts (Ault, supra, 13 Cal.3d at p. 117); measures taken before the event
§ 1152Offers and payments “in compromise or from humanitarian motives,” and statements in negotiation, to prove liabilitySubd. (b): in bad-faith actions (covenant of good faith or Ins. Code, § 790.03, subd. (h)), once one offer is admitted, related offers may come in for the same purpose. Subd. (c): partial payment and debt acknowledgments
§ 1154Claimant’s offer to accept less, to prove the claim invalidPurposes other than invalidity
§ 1155Liability insurance, “to prove negligence or other wrongdoing”Other purposes: research California case law (Federal Rule 411 lists some)
§ 1160Sympathy and “benevolent gestures” after an accident, “as evidence of an admission of liability”“A statement of fault … shall not be inadmissible”; “accident” excludes willful action
§ 1119Anything said, admissions and writings in a mediation or mediation consultation; not admissible or discoverable in civil actionsExceptions in §§ 1120–1124 (for example, signed settlement agreements meeting § 1123)

How are California’s hearsay exceptions organized?

Hearsay is “evidence of a statement that was made other than by a witness while testifying at the hearing and that is offered to prove the truth of the matter stated,” and it is inadmissible “[e]xcept as provided by law.” (§ 1200.) The exceptions are in Division 10, chapter 2 (§§ 1220–1390), arranged by article. The articles cover admissions, declarations against interest, prior statements of witnesses, spontaneous statements, state of mind, business records, official records, former testimony and judgments, among others.

Each level of a multiple-hearsay statement needs its own exception. (§ 1201.) In Sanchez, the Supreme Court used the example of an emergency-room report. The report “may be a business record,” while the patient’s statement inside it “may qualify as a statement of the patient’s existing mental or physical state (Evid. Code, § 1250, subd. (a)).” (Sanchez, supra, 63 Cal.4th at pp. 674–675.) California has no general hearsay exception for statements made for medical diagnosis or treatment; section 1253 is limited to child victims of abuse or neglect. Nor does California admit an employee’s statement against the employer merely because the employer is vicariously liable. (See the hearsay exceptions guide.)

Start with the California hearsay exceptions guide and gap table, then the exception-specific pages:

What limits apply to expert testimony under the California Evidence Code?

An expert opinion must relate to a subject “sufficiently beyond common experience that the opinion of an expert would assist the trier of fact,” and must rest on matter “of a type that reasonably may be relied upon by an expert.” (§ 801.) The court may require the expert to be examined on the basis first. (§ 802.) On objection, the court must exclude an opinion based “in whole or in significant part” on improper matter (§ 803), and ultimate-issue opinions are allowed (§ 805).

Under sections 801, subdivision (b), and 802, “the trial court acts as a gatekeeper to exclude expert opinion testimony that is (1) based on matter of a type on which an expert may not reasonably rely, (2) based on reasons unsupported by the material on which the expert relies, or (3) speculative.” (Sargon, supra, 55 Cal.4th at pp. 771–772.) That preliminary determination “is not a decision on its persuasiveness.” (Id. at p. 772.) For new scientific techniques, the Kelly general-acceptance test still applies. (Id. at p. 772, fn. 6, citing People v. Leahy (1994) 8 Cal.4th 587, 604; see Kelly, supra, 17 Cal.3d at p. 30.)

Three PI-specific points:

How do you authenticate writings, photos and recordings in California?

“Authentication of a writing is required before it may be received in evidence.” (§ 1401.) Authentication means “the introduction of evidence sufficient to sustain a finding that it is the writing that the proponent of the evidence claims it is” (§ 1400), the same prima facie standard as section 403.

The content of a writing may be proved by “otherwise admissible secondary evidence.” The exceptions are a genuine dispute about material terms where justice requires exclusion, or where admission would be unfair. (§ 1521 (the Secondary Evidence Rule).)

For subpoenaed business records, the custodian’s affidavit under section 1561 and the presumption in section 1562 can replace live testimony, but only “if the requirements of Section 1271 have been met.” See the § 1271 business records guide.

Which presumptions and Vehicle Code evidence rules come up in auto cases?

Negligence per se (§ 669). Failure to exercise due care is presumed if four things are shown. The person violated a statute, ordinance or regulation of a public entity; the violation proximately caused death or injury; the injury resulted from an occurrence the law was designed to prevent; and the injured person was in the protected class. (§ 669, subd. (a).) The presumption is rebuttable under subdivision (b), and section 669 sits in the Code’s article on presumptions affecting the burden of proof. The pattern instruction is CACI No. 418. For common predicate statutes, see our pages on Vehicle Code section 21950 and Vehicle Code section 22350.

Vehicle Code exclusions. Several Vehicle Code sections keep common auto-case evidence away from the jury, or limit what it proves. Most sit in the “Civil Actions” article of the Vehicle Code chapter titled “Illegal Evidence.”

StatuteWhat it saysPractice consequence
Veh. Code, § 20013“No such accident report shall be used as evidence in any trial, civil or criminal, arising out of an accident,” apart from a DMV certificate showing whether a report was madeTraffic accident reports are “well established” as inadmissible, and an officer’s report also fails the business records and official records exceptions “irrespective of Vehicle Code section 20013”; see Box and Carlton below
Veh. Code, § 40832No DMV record of a license suspension or revocation, and no testimony “of or concerning or produced at the hearing” that led to it, is admissible “in any court in any civil action”Keep the DMV administrative per se outcome and hearing transcript out; prove the underlying conduct with other evidence
Veh. Code, § 40833The financial-responsibility report required by Vehicle Code sections 16000–16003 (commonly the SR-1), the DMV’s action and findings on it, and any security filed may not be “referred to in any way, or be any evidence of the negligence or due care of any party”Redact references to the SR-1 and DMV financial-responsibility action from exhibits and testimony
Veh. Code, § 40834A conviction for a Vehicle Code violation, or a local motor-vehicle ordinance, “shall not be res judicata or constitute a collateral estoppel of any issue determined therein in any subsequent civil action”A traffic conviction does not establish fault by preclusion; liability must still be proved
Veh. Code, § 40831Proof of speed above a prima facie limit in Vehicle Code section 22352 “does not establish negligence as a matter of law”; it must be established “as a fact” that the excess speed was negligentProve speed negligence as a fact, for example under the basic speed law, not only by the prima facie limit
Veh. Code, § 40830A violation required by federal law or orders, or by the Governor’s emergency orders, does not establish negligence as a matter of law; negligence “must be proved as a fact without regard to the violation”Watch for this defense where a driver claims a federal or emergency directive compelled the violation
§ 1300Hearsay exception only for a final judgment for “a crime punishable as a felony,” offered in a civil action to prove a fact essential to the judgment, “whether or not” based on a nolo pleaNo section 1300 route for an infraction or misdemeanor judgment. For non-felonies, a nolo plea also cannot be used as an admission in a civil suit on the same act (Pen. Code, § 1016, subd. 3). Whether a guilty plea can come in another way is a separate question; check current case law

Accident reports and the case law. Two decisions give section 20013 its working shape. Box v. California Date Growers Assn. (1976) 57 Cal.App.3d 266 called it “well established that traffic accident reports are not admissible in evidence,” affirmed the exclusion of the entire police report and the diagram in it, and upheld the reconstruction expert’s opinion on the motorcycle’s path after impact because a proper foundation was laid; the uncertainties went to weight, not admissibility. (Id. at pp. 270–271, 275.) Carlton v. Department of Motor Vehicles (1988) 203 Cal.App.3d 1428 added that a police officer’s accident report “would not be admissible under the business records or official records exceptions to the hearsay rule” irrespective of section 20013, and that the officer’s opinion that a driver was “most responsible” for the accident “is a legal conclusion and not a proper subject for expert opinion,” even if the officer testifies. (Id. at p. 1432.) The working rule for a reconstructionist is in our Sanchez guide: the expert may rely on the report and on scene facts, but the report itself, the witness statements in it, and the officer’s fault conclusion stay out unless they come in through live testimony with its own foundation.

Medical damages evidence. For privately insured plaintiffs, Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions, Inc. (2011) 52 Cal.4th 541 limits recovery of past medical expenses to “no more than the amounts paid by the plaintiff or his or her insurer for the medical services received or still owing at the time of trial.” (Id. at p. 566.) Where the provider accepted less by prior agreement, “evidence of the full billed amount is not itself relevant on the issue of past medical expenses.” (Id. at p. 567.) See the Howell medical damages evidence guide for lien-based treatment, uninsured plaintiffs and future-care issues.

Network-company (rideshare and delivery) auto cases. For accidents on or after January 1, 2027, Civil Code section 3333.9, added by Stats. 2026, ch. 17 (Sen. Bill No. 623), applies to claims against a network company, its subsidiary, or an app-based driver. Those terms are defined in Business and Professions Code section 7463, which covers delivery network companies and their couriers as well as transportation network companies and their drivers. Where the claimant treated with a lien-based provider, recovery for those medical services may not exceed the 70th percentile of FAIR Health, Inc.’s billed charges, or of a comparable commercially recognized billed-charges database, for the same or similar service in the area when it was rendered. (Civ. Code, § 3333.9, subd. (b)(1)(A).) The court may allow more before trial only on clear and convincing evidence, supported by expert testimony, of exceptionally rare or highly specialized treatment. (Id., subd. (b)(1)(C).) No party may present billed amounts above the recoverable amount, or refer to the section or the maximum; that evidence is “inadmissible for any purpose.” (Id., subd. (b)(2).) Bills below the maximum remain admissible. (Id., subd. (b)(3).) The Howell guide covers the details.

Which pages are in the series, and when were they last reviewed?

Each page shows its own “Legally reviewed” date. This register is updated whenever a page is re-reviewed.

PageStatusLast reviewed
California Evidence Code practitioner’s guide (this page)LiveOctober 26, 2026
Hearsay exceptions and California vs. FRE gap tableLiveOctober 26, 2026
§ 1271 business records foundation (with §§ 1560–1562)LiveOctober 26, 2026
Howell medical damages evidenceLiveOctober 26, 2026
§§ 1222–1224 authorized admissions and employee statementsLiveOctober 26, 2026
§§ 1240–1241 spontaneous statementsLiveOctober 26, 2026
Hearsay in expert testimony (Sanchez)LiveSeptember 20, 2026 (last reviewed)
§ 1280 official records and police reports; Veh. Code, § 20013; §§ 1220–1221; § 352 and motions in limine; § 669; § 1160; § 1151; §§ 1152, 1154; § 1155; §§ 1250–1253; §§ 1235–1236; § 1230; §§ 1290–1292; § 240; §§ 801–802 and SargonPlannedPending

Frequently asked questions

How specific does a California evidentiary objection have to be? Specific enough “to make clear the specific ground.” (§ 353.) State the ground and the section, and move to strike if the answer came first.

Does Evidence Code section 1151 bar subsequent remedial measures in a products case? Not on a strict-liability theory. Section 1151 does not apply where the defendant is alleged to be strictly liable. (Ault, supra, 13 Cal.3d at p. 117.)

Is an apology admissible in a California injury case? Sympathy statements are inadmissible to prove liability under section 1160, but a statement of fault made with them is not protected.

Does California follow Daubert? No. California has not adopted Daubert. Courts apply Evidence Code sections 801 and 802 as construed in Sargon (which draws on federal cases as persuasive authority) and, for new scientific techniques, the Kelly general-acceptance test.

Related pages

About the author

David Gammill is a California trial lawyer who served seven years as a Los Angeles County Deputy District Attorney and has tried more than 100 cases to verdict. He represents injured people in the South Bay and across Los Angeles County. State Bar of California No. 258286 (State Bar profile).

Have a case headed for trial?

Gammill Law works with other lawyers as trial counsel, as co-counsel, and on referred personal injury, wrongful death and civil rights cases. Any fee division is handled in writing under California Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5.1, with the client’s written consent. To discuss a case, call 310-750-4149 and ask for David Gammill, or see For Attorneys.

This page is general educational material for lawyers, not legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes and case law change; verify current law and the Official Reports before relying on any statement here.

CallFree Case Review
Ask Gammill AI Calculator