Menu
Call
Contact
Blog

$6.2 Million Wrongful Termination Verdict: The Secret Recording Case

  • No fee unless we win
  • 5.0 on Google
  • Avvo 10.0 Superb
  • Super Lawyers 2026 & 2027
David Gammill, trial attorney and founder of Gammill Law Accident & Injury Lawyers in Torrance, California

$100,000,000+

Recovered for Clients

$21,100,000

Wrongful Death VERDICT

$16,000,000

School Sexual Abuse VERDICT

$12,000,000

Whistleblower Retaliation VERDICT

By David Gammill, trial counsel in this case · Last reviewed: September 10, 2026

When two employees reported what they believed was illegal activity inside a California company, the company did not just fire them. It sued them. Seven years later, after a three-week jury trial in Los Angeles Superior Court, a jury answered every question on the verdict form in the employees’ favor: $6,190,126 in damages, a finding by clear and convincing evidence that both the company and one of its executives acted with malice, oppression, or fraud, and zero on the company’s lawsuit against them. Before the punitive damages phase could be tried, the case resolved by confidential settlement. This is the story of how that case was built and tried. Every case is different, and no past result guarantees any future outcome.

  • The claims: wrongful termination and workplace harassment. The report came first; the decision to fire came days later.
  • The counterattack: the company sued its own former employees. The jury awarded it nothing.
  • The evidence: deleted email accounts, missing messages, and a recording the defense swore was made openly, until the trial proved it was secret.
  • The verdict: $6,190,126, every question answered for the plaintiffs, and punitive damages found available against both the company and an individual executive.
  • The ending: a confidential settlement, reached before the punitive damages phase was tried.

Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee a future outcome. If you were fired for a reason the law does not allow, call Gammill Law Accident & Injury Lawyers at (310) 750-4149 for a free, confidential consultation.

The Report

This case started the way most of these cases start: employees saw something at work they believed was illegal, and they said so. The two had worked at the company about a year. They did not go to the press. They reported it the way California law contemplates, inside the company, to people with the authority to do something about it.

California Labor Code section 1102.5 prohibits an employer from punishing an employee for reporting information the employee has reasonable cause to believe shows a violation of the law, whether the report goes to a government agency, to a supervisor, or to another employee with authority to investigate it. The protection applies whether or not reporting is part of the person’s job. A firing that punishes a protected report is a wrongful termination, no matter what reason appears in the personnel file.

Fired Within Days

The report was made on April 24. By May 5, the company had decided the two would be terminated.

No company announces that it is firing someone for speaking up. There is no memo that says so. What a jury can see is the sequence, and here the sequence was eleven days. Timelines matter. That arithmetic sat at the center of the case from the first day of trial to the last.

Sued by Their Own Employer

The company denied everything. Then it went further: it filed a cross-complaint against the two people who had reported it. That decision changed the stakes of the entire case. The plaintiffs were no longer just pursuing their claims; they were defendants in their former employer’s lawsuit. Losing would not have meant walking away with nothing. It could have meant owing money to the company that fired them.

They did not fold. The lawsuits were filed in 2017. The company litigated for seven years before a jury ever heard the evidence.

The Evidence That Wasn’t There

Some of the most important evidence in this case was evidence the jury never saw. Email accounts that would have held key communications had been deleted, and the court instructed the jury that if it found evidence had been willfully suppressed, it could conclude that evidence would have been unfavorable to the party that suppressed it. The pattern ran deeper than email. Everybody has text messages; the defense produced almost none of its own. Our case did not depend on what was missing. The jury was entitled to weigh it anyway, and the law told them so.

Their Best Evidence: The Secret Recording

The defense came to trial holding what it plainly considered its best evidence: a recording of the plaintiffs, offered to destroy their credibility. The defense told the jury there was nothing improper about it, that it was made openly, in plain sight, with permission.

We did not fight to keep that recording out. We stipulated it into evidence.

At trial, the recording itself gave the truth away. Examined moment by moment, timestamp by timestamp, it carried the unmistakable signature of a concealed device, and the account of an open, permitted recording came apart in front of the jury. By the close of evidence, the defense’s centerpiece exhibit had changed sides: a recording offered to undermine two fired employees had become the plaintiffs’ proof of how they were actually treated. And when the lawyers argued housekeeping before deliberations, it was the plaintiffs who asked the court to make sure the jurors knew they could listen to the full recording at their leisure. The defense preferred to wait and see. When the side that brought the evidence no longer wants the jury spending time with it, that tells you how the trial went.

Three Weeks in Trial

The trial ran three weeks in Los Angeles Superior Court. Witness by witness, document by document, two directly conflicting accounts of why these employees lost their jobs went to a jury. The rebuttal argument put the jury’s whole job into one question, repeated until it became the credibility test for everything the defense had said: which is which, and who is who.

The Verdict: A Clean Sweep

Closing arguments finished on September 25, 2024. The next day, the jury came back. Every question on the special verdict form, the liability questions, the damages questions, the punitive damages questions, and the company’s cross-complaint, was answered in the plaintiffs’ favor. Every one.

  • $6,190,126 in total damages for the two plaintiffs.
  • Punitive damages found available against both defendants. The jury found that the company and an individual executive acted with malice, oppression, or fraud, and made that finding by clear and convincing evidence, a higher standard of proof than the one governing most civil claims. Under California’s punitive damages statute, that finding is what opens the door to a punitive damages award.
  • Zero on the cross-complaint. The company’s lawsuit against its own former employees recovered nothing.

As we put it in closing argument: “They don’t get a discount because they waited to be forced to do the right thing.”

Every case is different, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

The Settlement Before Round Two

The trial was structured in two phases. Phase one decided liability, compensatory damages, and whether punitive damages were available. Phase two, in front of the same jury that had just answered every question against the defendants, would have decided how much. It was set to begin the following week.

Phase two was never tried. After the verdict, and before the punitive damages phase began, the case resolved by confidential settlement. The terms are confidential, and they will stay that way.

What This Case Means for Yours

  1. You do not have to prove your employer actually broke the law. Section 1102.5 protects a report you had reasonable cause to believe disclosed a violation. If you were fired for making one, that is a wrongful termination case even if the underlying issue was never proven.
  2. Timelines are evidence. Wrongful termination is proven by sequence, documents, and testimony far more often than by confession. If you reported something and the consequences came fast, the calendar itself is part of your case. Preserve everything, starting now.
  3. A counterattack is not the end. Employers sometimes answer an employee’s claim by suing the employee. In this case the jury zeroed that lawsuit. It raised the stakes; it did not change the facts.
  4. Defendants price cases on who will actually try them. Most cases settle; the ones that settle fairly are the ones the other side believes will be tried. This case settled only after a jury had answered every single question.

Talk to the Lawyer Who Tried This Case

David Gammill served seven years as a Deputy District Attorney before representing plaintiffs. A prosecutor proves cases under the highest burden the law imposes: beyond a reasonable doubt. He has tried over 100 cases to verdict. If you were fired and the reason does not hold up, get your free case evaluation or call (310) 750-4149. There are no upfront legal fees; a fee is collected only if we win, under a written contingency fee agreement that complies with California law. If you were fired for a reason the law does not allow, the firm handles wrongful termination cases throughout Los Angeles County, and our guide to California wrongful termination law explains the rules, including Labor Code section 1102.5, that a case like this one turns on.

Disclaimer: This page describes a specific case tried to a Phase 1 jury verdict in September 2024 and subsequently resolved by confidential settlement. Its facts, parties, and circumstances are unique, and the result does not constitute a guarantee, warranty, or prediction regarding the outcome of any other matter. Details are drawn from the public trial record; party names are omitted. This page is attorney advertising.

CallFree Case Review
Ask Gammill AI Calculator